Rule Changes

Summary of Rule Changes for the 2019 MTSEF

SRC and IRB pre-approvals – Projects requiring pre-approval CAN NOT be conducted until approval is received from the SRC or IRB.

      • Are you unsure if your project will require pre-approval?  Check the
        Rules Wizard
      • SRC meets monthly.  Final project pre-approval submission deadline is Friday, January 4, 2019.
      • IRB meets as projects are submitted for pre-approval.  Final project pre-approval submission deadline is Friday, November 30, 2018.
      • Check International Rules for changes HERE

Notable changes noted from ISEF 2019

  • General Clarifications 
    • Minor changes in wording (spelling, grammar, formatting)
    • P. 4 – New section on digital paperwork and signatures
    • All sections (human participant, vertebrate animals, PHBAs, hazardous substances) have been realigned to state general rules first and put exemptions at the end of the section.
  • Human Participant Clarifications (See Rules for complete descriptions of criteria) 
    • Removed expedited review. Any project that requires IRB approval requires full approval.
    • Clarification of Regulated Research Institution IRB and School IRB
    • New section on human participant involvement in student-designed invention, prototype, computer application and engineering/design projects
  • Vertebrate Animals 
    • P. 10 Rule 6 – 15% is the maximum permissible weight loss for experimental animals compared to control group.
  • PHBA’s 
    • P. 14 B – Describes conditions under which various rDNA technologies may be conducted.
    • See this link for summary of these rule changes for 2018-19.

Middle School Limitations

  • The goal of the fair is to allow all project entries from grades 9-12 and the best from grades 6-8.
  • Each grade 6-8 school will be allowed at least 3 entries per grade.
  • Schools submitting winning 1st, 2nd, or 3rd category awards in the previous year’s fair will be allowed additional entries.
  • The formula is (3 x Category Awards in grade in previous fair  + 1) x 2 = allowed entries in that grade for present fair.
  • Schools receiving additional entries for 2018 are APL Science, Bellevue Middle, Cameron: A Lead Public School, Cascade School, Faith Home School Tutorial, and Haynes Middle School.
  • For these schools, the total entries allowed for these schools for 2018 fair will be:
    • APL Science = 8 in 6th, 3 in 7th, 8 in 8th
    • Bellevue Middle School = 8 in 6th, 8 in 7th, 3 in 8th
    • Cameron: A Lead Public School = 14 in 6th
    • Cameron: College Prep = 3 in 6th, 3 in 7th, 8 in 8th
    • Cascade School = 3 in 6th, 8 in 7th, 8 in 8th
    • Faith Home School Tutorial = 3 in 6th, 20 in 7th, 8 in 8th
    • Haynes Middle School = 8 in 6th, 3 in 7th, 3 in 8th
  • Middle Schools will have to validate their entries with the signature of a certifying official. This can be the school science fair coordinator or an administrator. Middle Schools are encouraged to have qualifying school fairs to determine their entries. Middle School Certification form
Advertisements